ESER Home Surveillance Land Management Education Reserach Risk Assessment Conservation Management Publications Links Feedback

ESER Logo

 

 

Breeding Bird Survey Results 2005 (continued)

RESULTS AND DISCUSSION

Bird abundance and species richness

Abundance -  A total of 6,726 individual birds were recorded along the 14 survey routes (Figure 2). This is above the annual mean of 4,917 birds (no surveys were conducted in 1992 or 1993).

Horned larks (Eremophila alpestris) were the most abundant species recorded on the INL during 2005. Horned larks comprised of more than 30 percent of all birds counted, occurred on all routes, and on 87 percent of stops (Table1a,1b, 1c).

Other common species were western meadowlark (Sturnella neglecta), Brewer’s sparrow (Spizella breweri), and sage thrashers (Oreoscoptes montanus), each of which occurred at more than 300 stops along all 14 routes (Table1a,1b, 1c). These four species account for approximately 65 percent of all birds counted. Mourning doves (Zenaida macroura) and brown-headed cowbirds (Molothrus ater) also occurred along each of the 14 routes but in smaller numbers than the preceding species. Although sage sparrows (Amphispiza belli) were the fifth most abundant bird recorded during 2005, it only occurred on 13 of the 14 routes.

The high numbers of birds counted in 2005, however, does not necessarily reflect large numbers of birds counted among all taxa. Many species observed were neither widespread nor abundant. Of the 71 species recorded in 2005, 20 species (28 percent) occurred along only one of the 14 routes, and 37 species (52 percent) were represented by fewer than ten individuals (Table1a,1b, 1c). Additionally, many species were at or below long-term averages and a few species observed in six or more previous years were absent in 2005 including: bank swallow (Riparia riparia), northern shoveler (Anas clypeata), and American avocet (Recurvirostra americana). Instead, the total count was inflated by high counts of horned lark and western meadowlark. Several species recorded during 2005 do not actively nest on the INL. These include American white pelican (Pelecanus erythrorhynchos), Franklin’s gull (Larus pipixcan), ring-billed gull (Larus
delawarensis
), mountain bluebird (Sialia currucoides), and rough-legged hawk (Buteo lagopus).

Overall, 14 routes were surveyed on the INL with approximately 180 km2 total area surveyed (Table 2). This represents about 8 percent of the INL. Each remote route surveyed an area of approximately 25 km2 with an average of 27.9 birds observed per km2. The Tractor Flat route continues to have the highest density of birds with 33.3 birds observed per km2. The area surveyed on the nine facility complex routes ranged from 3 km2 at WTF to more than 12 km2 at TAN. This is a total of approximately 55 km2 surveyed at the facilities. The highest density of birds observed on a facility route was at MFC which averaged 101 birds observed per km2. This number was inflated due to the large number of Franklin’s gulls observed during the survey using the man-made ponds at MFC. The area surveyed at each stop on remote routes is greater than the area surveyed at each stop on the facility routes, so comparisons between facility and remote routes are not analogous. Appendix A contains a list of species observed and their relative abundance along the 14 survey routes.

Overall, the five most numerous species in order of abundance were horned larks, western meadowlarks, Brewer's sparrows, sage thrasher, and sage sparrows. More than 70 percent of all birds detected in 2005 are the above five species, which are typically the most frequently counted species on the INL.

Species Richness - In 2005, 71 species were detected during the surveys. This is the greatest number of species recorded during a breeding bird survey at the INL (Figure 3) and is well above the average of 57 ± 4 recorded from 1985-2004. In 2005, there were 24 ± 3 species per route, with many similar species recorded along remote routes (25 ± 7) and facility routes (24 ± 4). The fewest number of species (N=16) was observed along the Circular Butte route while TRA had the greatest number of species (N=36).

Species assemblages - In addition to the density of individuals and the number of species recorded on the INL, the composition of species in relation to habitat is an important indicator to ecological health.

Waterfowl - Nine species of waterfowl (order Anseriformes, family Anatidae) were observed during the 2005 survey which contributed <1 percent (Figure 4) to the total individuals observed. Gadwall (Anas Strepera) was the most abundant species and occurred along five of nine facility routes. Waterfowl have limited distribution on the INL and occur either in natural areas along the Big Lost River or in man-made ponds near facilities. Waterfowl counts at the INL were slightly below the long term average and only observed at the facility wastewater treatment ponds. Natural waterways located on the INL (The Big Lost River, Sinks and Spreading Areas) have not contained water since summer of 1999, thus reducing the number of birds that would otherwise use these areas.

Shorebirds, Grebes, Gulls, Pelicans and Waders – Eight species of shorebirds/gulls and terns/grebes/pelicans and wading birds were observed (Table1a,1b, 1c). Of these, only three were observed on remote routes, three were only observed on facility routes, and the other two occurred along both types of routes. The most abundant was Franklin’s gull which was observed along one remote and one facility route. This was the first time the American white pelican was documented on the INL during the annual BBS. Pelicans typically nest on a low mound of earth and debris on a marshy island and occasionally on rocky islands in desert lakes. Therefore these birds were most likely migrating through the INL. No wading birds were observed during the 2005 survey.

Like waterfowl, many shorebirds and wading birds are closely tied to water, which is currently only available at waste-water ponds near facilities or adjacent agricultural fields. Shorebirds/gulls and terns/grebes/pelicans and wading birds represent 3 percent of all individual birds observed (Figure 4). This number is inflated due to the large number of Franklin’s gulls observed migrating through the INL.

Raptors and Corvids - Nine species of raptors (eagles, falcons, hawks, and owls) were observed along the survey routes. One percent of all birds counted were raptors (Figure 4). Red-tailed hawk (Buteo Jamaicensis) and ferruginous hawk (Buteo regalis) were the most abundant species on both facility (N=6 and 5) and remote routes (N=13 and 10). Although common during the winter, rough-legged hawks were observed for the first time during the 2005 BBS. We presume that these individuals were just passing through to the breeding grounds farther north.

Corvidae is a family of birds which contains the ravens and crows (Genus Corvus), magpies (Genus Pica), and jays (Genus Perisoreus, Gymnorhinus, and Nucifraga). Common ravens (Corvus corax) were the most abundant corvid (N=89) and were observed on all routes. More ravens were observed on remote routes and raven populations continue to increase across the INL (Figure 5). Raptors and corvids constituted 2 percent of the total individuals observed
(Figure 4).

Urbanized and Exotic Species - Species associated with human activities (introduced species, or species associated with human-altered landscapes) typically occur on facility routes rather than remote routes. House sparrow (Passer domesticus), house wren (Troglodytes aedon), American robin (Turdus migratorius), and rock pigeon (Columba livia) were only observed on facility routes. Although barn swallow (Hirundo rustica), house finch (Carpodacus mexicanus), and European starlings (Sturnus vulgaris) were observed on both facility and remote routes they occurred in much smaller numbers on the remote routes. Urbanized and exotic species made up 2 percent of all individual birds observed during the 2005 survey (Figure 4).

Sagebrush Obligates - Even though sagebrush obligate numbers continue to be below the long term average, the trend in population abundance remains stable for both facility and remote routes (Figure 6). On remote routes, sagebrush obligates were most often observed (per km²) on the Tractor Flat route during the 2005 survey. Over the long term, sagebrush obligates occurred most often on the Big Lost River route, but since the 2000 Tin Cup fire their populations have dramatically declined. Brewer’s sparrow was the most abundant sagebrush-obligate species on both remote and facility routes (Table 3a, 3b). Twenty-four percent of the total number of birds observed during the 2005 Breeding Bird Survey were sagebrush obligates (Figure 4).

Other Common Shrub-steppe/Grassland Species - Common shrub-steppe/grassland species that occur on the INL include horned lark, western meadowlark, Brewer’s blackbird (Euphagus cyanocelphalus), brown-headed cowbird, common nighthawk (Chordeiles minor), mourning dove and vesper sparrow (Pooecetes gramineus). Of all individual birds observed during the 2005, more than 54 percent are shrub-steppe/grassland species (Figure 4). Although more shrub-steppe/grassland species were observed on remote routes, the number per km² was much greater on facility routes with the most species observed per km² at MFC. Horned lark and western meadowlark were the most common species recorded and occurred on all routes. Although horned lark populations appear to be stabilizing they continue to increase across the INL and have reached record numbers on both facility and remote routes (Figure 7). This increase is likely the result of a land cover change from shrub-steppe to grasslands caused by wildfires.

Species of special concern - The sagebrush steppe habitat on the INL continues to support species of birds that are low or declining in number throughout the Intermountain West. Species of special concern are more often observed on remote routes than facility routes. Nine species with a state rank of rare or uncommon, imperiled, or critically imperiled recorded in 2005 including American white pelican (N=6), ferruginous hawk (N=15), long-billed curlew (Numenius americanus) (N=9), Franklin’s gull (N=123), ring-billed gull (N=2), western burrowing owl (Athene cunicularia) (N=4), loggerhead shrike (Lanius ludovicianus) (N=40), northern mockingbird (Mimus polyglottos) (N=1), and lark bunting (Calamospiza melanocorys) (N=4). This is the first year that the American white pelican was observed during the annual BBS. Although Franklin’s gull was the most abundant species of special concern during the 2005 survey, they are closely tied to cicada hatches on the INL and agricultural fields where they spend time foraging. The most common and routinely observed sensitive species are loggerhead shrike, ferruginous hawk and long-billed curlew whose populations have remained stable or slightly decreased since the BBS began in 1985 (Figure 8).

SUMMARY (next page)


Related Topics:


Home | Background | SurveillanceLand Management | Education | Research | Risk Assessment | Publications |  Links | Feedback | Opportunities