Breeding Bird Survey Results 2007                          Stoller-ESER-111

RESULTS AND DISCUSSION

Summary Statistics

A total of 5412 birds were documented during this year’s survey. The 2007 total abundance was greater than the 1985-2007 average of 4991 birds (Figure 2). No BBS surveys were conducted on the INL in 1992 or 1993. There were a total of 69 unique species (i.e., species richness) recorded during this year’s survey. This year is above the average species richness of 59 for all BBS routes combined. Of the remote routes, only Kyle Canyon is slightly below the average of 25 species with 22 recorded this year, and all other remote routes were above the average richness.

The Tractor Flats remote route had the greatest bird abundance with 853 individuals observed (Table 1). Since 1985 the Tractor Flats route has the greatest average abundance of all BBS routes with mean bird abundance of 711 individuals. This year the Tractor Flats route also contained the greatest species richness with 30 different species recorded.

Horned lark (Eremophila alpestris) was the most abundant species observed during the 2007 survey with 1416 individuals counted representing 26 percent of all observations (Table 2). Horned Lark is continually the most abundant species recorded during the INL BBS. This species was observed on 83 percent (408) of the total stops made during the entire survey.

The five most abundant birds are horned lark (n = 1416), western meadowlark (Sturnella neglecta; n = 987), Brewer’s sparrow (Spizella breweri; n = 528), sage sparrow (Amphispiza belli; n = 459), and sage thrasher (Oreoscoptes montanus; n = 410). These five species comprise over 72 percent of all observations made in 2007. These five species were also the most abundant in the 2006 BBS survey, and were observed on every remote and facility route surveyed. In the 21 years of INL breeding bird surveys, these five species have been the most abundant 16 times, and are among the six most abundant species recorded in all years. Horned larks, western meadowlarks, Brewer’s sparrow, and Sage sparrows have all experienced significant population declines in Breeding Bird Surveys across their range (Peterjohn and Sauer 1999). Given the fact that many additional sagebrush obligates are exhibiting population declines due to suspected habitat loss and disturbance, it is encouraging to see consistently high abundance among these species.

Rare Observations and Species of Special Concern

New species to the INL BBS have been found throughout the duration of these surveys, and additional species were added to the list this year. This survey yielded four new species observations never recorded in prior surveys on the INL. A single greater scaup (Aythya marila), bald eagle (Haliaeetus leucocephalus), osprey (Pandion haliaetus), and turkey vulture (Cathartes aura) were observed during the 2007 BBS.

The sagebrush steppe habitat on the INL is relatively pristine and undisturbed and continually supports a high abundance of species that are showing signs of decline in comparable areas in the western U.S. There were six species observed during the 2007 BBS that have been assigned an Idaho state ranking of critically imperiled or imperiled (Idaho Conservation Data Center 2008) including greater sage-grouse (Centrocercus urophasianus; n=4), ferruginous hawk (Buteo regalis; n=8), long-billed curlew (Numenius americanus; n=7), Franklin’s gull (Larus pipixcan; n=178), Brewer’s sparrow (n=528), and the grasshopper sparrow (Ammodramus savannarum; n=102).

SPECIES ASSEMBLAGE SUMMARY

Observed bird assemblage proportions can be considered in the context of the habitat composition within a region to provide useful insight about general ecological health. For example, if a study area contains large shrubland and grassland habitat patches and the corresponding bird assemblage observations are low, this may be an indication the local population is threatened or experiencing population declines.

The most abundant species assemblage was the shrub-steppe and grassland category representing 59 percent of all BBS observations (Figure 3). The shrub-steppe and grassland bird assemblage always dominates the observed bird abundance as the majority of the INL is composed of shrub-steppe and grassland habitats. The second most abundant species assemblage is sagebrush obligates representing 26 percent of all observations. Given the regional concern for sagebrush obligate species, it is encouraging to see that obligates are doing well on the INL.

Shrub-steppe and Grassland

This species assemblage has always yielded the greatest number of observations in past BBS and continues to dominate the observations in 2007 with 3231 individuals representing 59 percent of the total observations. Common shrub-steppe and grassland species include horned lark, western meadowlark, brown-headed cowbird (Molothrus ater), and vesper sparrows (Pooecetes gramineus). Horned lark (n = 1416) and western meadowlark (n = 987) were the most abundant species within this assemblage, and were also the top two abundant species for the entire survey. Horned lark abundance has steadily risen across the INL as wildfire continues to impact and alter the plant communities across the site converting shrub dominated communities into more grassland dominated vegetation communities.

Sagebrush Obligates

The sagebrush obligate assemblage had the second largest species abundance with 1401 individuals representing 26 percent of all observations. This assemblage contains four species including Brewer’s sparrow, sage sparrow, sage thrasher, and greater sage-grouse. Brewer’s sparrow was the most abundant sagebrush obligate with 528 individuals counted. These data suggest that the sagebrush obligates are thriving on the INL which contains fairly undisturbed sagebrush-steppe habitat in the Intermountain west. In many other western states, sagebrush obligates are facing significant habitat loss and conversion, and consequently sagebrush obligate species are showing population declines. The population trend across the INL shows a consistent high abundance of sagebrush obligates (Vilord 2007).

Raptors and Corvids

The raptor and corvid assemblage contained 193 observations representing 4 percent of the total observations. Twelve species of raptors (eagles, hawks, falcons, and owls) were recorded. Red-tailed hawk (Buteo jamaicensis) was the most abundant raptor species detected with 39 individuals, and marks the highest abundance ever recorded for this species during the INL BBS. Other notable observations include the first INL BBS records for bald eagle, osprey, and turkey vulture.

The Corivdae family includes ravens and crows, magpies, and jays. The common raven (Corvus corax) was the most abundant species within this assemblage with 89 individuals. The raven population on the INL has shown a steady increase and the 2007 raven abundance ties 2005 for the highest numbers ever recorded. Recent research has shown that ravens negatively impact sage-grouse nest success (Coates 2007), and the continued increase in raven abundance may become a concern as sage-grouse populations exhibit declines across the western U.S.

Urbanized and Exotics

This species assemblage represents birds associated with urban or human-altered environments, and are most commonly found around facilities. Example species include European starling (Sturnus vulgaris), rock pigeon (Columba livia), and American robin (Turdus migratorius). This assemblage constitutes 4 percent of the total observations in 2007 with 210 total individuals. Barn swallows (Hirundo rustica) were the most abundant species in this assemblage with 75 individuals followed closely by European starlings with 57 individuals.

Waterfowl

Waterfowl are commonly reported on the BBS despite the fact the INL contains very little standing water. With the exception of the ephemeral and sporadic presence of the Big Lost River and Sinks wetland, the only standing water bodies on the INL consist of wastewater treatment ponds found near facilities. These man-made ponds serve as stopover locations for migrating birds and a number of different species have been observed using these sites since 1985.

There were nine waterfowl species documented with an abundance of 149 individuals representing about 3 percent of the total observations. The number of waterfowl observations was primarily driven by a single large flock of Canada geese (n = 95) from the Test Area North (TAN) survey route. Many species within this assemblage included only a few individuals and contributed the lowest assemblage proportion of total bird observations.

Shorebirds

The shorebird assemblage including grebes, gulls, and waders had low combined abundance with eight species detected this year. There were a total of 228 individuals representing 4 percent of the total BBS observations. Due to the lack of standing water across the INL, most observations within the shorebird assemblage occurred in proximity to waste ponds at facilities. The total number of observations was influenced by two large flocks of Franklin’s gulls (60 and 81 birds) counted along the Tractor Flats route representing 62 percent of all shorebird observations. The close proximity of the Tractor Flats route to Mud Lake agricultural areas can explain why so many gulls were observed. Without the inclusion of Franklin’s gull, this assemblage would only contribute about 1 percent of all observations.

BIRD ABUNDANCE CORRELATION (next page)
 


Related Topics:


Home | Background | Surveillance Land Management | Education | Research | Risk Assessment | Publications |  Links | Feedback | Opportunities